Who would you rather fight?

If you had to choose to fight someone in a no ruled fight to the death match, say that both guys (or girls) were equal size and both trained in the same martial art, except one has trained 10 years but has never been in a real fight, tournament or did sparing and the other guy had only one year training but has had 10 street fights in that time

Who would you rather fight?
I would go for the first one. Real fights are different from training. Last time i fought, the guy have 5 years karate tournament experience but he's terrible in a street fight. I never even got a scratch. ^_^
Reply:the girl with a ten yrs trainin cause once you were in a street fight you can pretty much rip off anyone's head...
Reply:the one that hasnt been in the streetfights man. experience and being able to control your emotions in a fight means everything!
Reply:without real world "training" or real world fights you are in for the shock of your life...
Reply:The guy who has actually fought.





With the first one not doing any sparring essentially what they have learned will be worthless in a street fight (or any fight for that matter). 10 years of bad training doesn't help versus someone with real fighting experience.





10 fights in a year? That is honestly a lot of experience. Having that kind of experience, plus having a knowledge of the Martial Art (one year would give you enough to figure out it's strengths and weaknesses) would pretty much make the guy with the streetfights a very clear and evident victor.








%26lt;edit%26gt; Ooops!





Thanks Jim R.





I thought this was another who would win scenario...





I would totally fight the guy who has never sparred.





Of course it does matter if the guy who has been streetfighting has won those 10 fights.. or at least a few of them. If he got his @ss kicked 10 times, then I would fight him hehe.





Thanks Jim!
Reply:judomofo,why did you choose the more dangerous of these two fighters?


The question is: Who would you rather fight?





EDIT: No Problem judomofo
Reply:Doesn't matter who you'd rather fight, that's not who you're gonna get which is why real martial artists train hard.





Flip a coin and pray, that's real life.
Reply:Anything can happen in a fight, but if two people are fighting, and only one has been in a fight before, my money is on the one with experience.